NEW DELHI: The Congress on Saturday alleged that India’s debt has nearly “tripled” to Rs 155 lakh crore in the nine years under Prime Minister Narendra Modi and demanded a white paper on the state of the economy.
Congress spokesperson Supriya Shrinate alleged the Modi government’s “economic mismanagement” is responsible for the present state of the economy and claimed that Rs 100 lakh crore of debt has been added since the present dispensation assumed charge in 2014.
“As chief minister of Gujarat, Mr Modi used to blame those on the other side of the political spectrum as inefficient, incompetent and corrupt — adjectives that today suit him and his government more than anyone else because economic mismanagement of this government has led to a ruined Indian economy. It resulted in high prices, inflation, and high unemployment and has now resulted in a massive debt burden that the country is facing.
“After ruining India’s economic growth story, creating huge unemployment, raging inflation, Mr Modi has done the unthinkable, which is an addition of over Rs 100 lakh crore to India’s debt, which is at an alarming level,” she said at a press conference.
The Congress leader further said India’s debt in 2014 was at Rs 55 lakh crore, which has now gone past Rs 155 lakh crore.
She claimed that India’s debt under 14 prime ministers in 67 years was Rs 55 lakh crore while Modi alone has increased it by over Rs 100 lakh crore.
“Economic management is not the same thing as headline management. The Indian economy cannot be managed by managing headlines. It cannot be done through teleprompters and definitely not through WhatsApp forwards. The Indian economy will have to be managed by sound economic managers who don’t want to hog the limelight. Who wants to do the work and fix the Indian economy and ensure that prosperity reaches every part of India?
“We demand a white paper on the Indian economy because the fault lines are only getting deeper,” she said.
Shrinate also claimed that the bottom 50 per cent of Indians who own three per cent of the country’s wealth paid 64 per cent of the GST collected. The richest 10 per cent, on the other hand, own 80 per cent of the country’s wealth but pay only three per cent of the GST collected.
India has the costliest LPG cylinder, the third costliest petrol and the eighth costliest diesel in the world, Shrinate claimed.
The Congress leader said a debt of Rs 155 lakh crore means every Indian is reeling under a burden of Rs 1.20 lakh.
“The Modi government in its tenure has bought debt of Rs 4 lakh rupees every second,” she claimed.
The Congress spokesperson also added that the government has to pay an annual interest of Rs 11 lakh crore on this debt.
India’s debt-to-GDP ratio has risen to 84 per cent, Shrinate claimed, and said it is alarming when compared to other developing and emerging market economies where the average debt-to-GDP ratio is at 64.5 per cent.
“India is bearing an annual cost of Rs 11 lakh crore to service this mounting debt. Questions are now being raised on India’s debt servicing capacity. According to the CAG report, government debt was 52.5 per cent of GDP in 2019-20 and the debt sustainability had turned negative that year. With debt at 84 per cent of the GDP, debt sustainability is suspect,” she asserted.
“But, the big question is who are the beneficiaries of this rising debt because quite clearly it is not the poor, not the middle class and not the MSMEs. Twenty-three crore people have been pushed below the poverty line, 83 per cent Indians have seen their incomes dip, over 11,000 MSMEs have shut down in a single year but the number of billionaires in India have gone up from 102 in 2020 to 166 over two years.
“But are all these rich beneficiaries of high debt playing their part in India’s growth or paying higher taxes?” Shrinate asked and said the government should turn its focus to the other important issue of tax collection.
Price rise and unemployment, besides income disparity, have emerged as major issues, she said.
“The bottom 50 per cent of India’s population that owns just three per cent of the country’s total wealth is paying 64 per cent of the GST collected. In contrast, the top 10 per cent richest Indians, who own 80 per cent of the country’s wealth, pay merely 3-4 per cent of the GST collected,” the Congress leader claimed.
“The government is clearly in denial because it is certain that an indirect tax like the GST or excise duty on fuel has hurt the poor the most. India’s consumption has been consistently weak. The recently released GDP figures that the government touted as a great achievement has a very big red flag — India’s consumption-to-GDP ratio has fallen from 61.1 per cent in FY 2022 to 60.6 per cent in FY 2023,” she said.
Asked if India is on a path similar to Sri Lanka and Pakistan, she said, “No, I am not going to sit here and say that we can go the Sri Lanka and the Pakistan way.”
Elaborating further on her stance, the Congress leader said, “I think the fundamentals of our economy are strong, they need to be strengthened. I don’t think I am going to sit here and do rumour-mongering. But yes, while the fundamentals are strong, perhaps, we have a consumption story. We have an India that will spend if you put money in their hands but the reality also is that in the last nine years there has been no focus on economic management.”
She added, “The mainstay of the Indian economy is consumption. Any government should lose sleep if consumption begins to default and that is what is happening. If consumption begins to default, we must worry, but I will not do rumour-mongering.”
Congress spokesperson Supriya Shrinate alleged the Modi government’s “economic mismanagement” is responsible for the present state of the economy and claimed that Rs 100 lakh crore of debt has been added since the present dispensation assumed charge in 2014.
“As chief minister of Gujarat, Mr Modi used to blame those on the other side of the political spectrum as inefficient, incompetent and corrupt — adjectives that today suit him and his government more than anyone else because economic mismanagement of this government has led to a ruined Indian economy. It resulted in high prices, inflation, and high unemployment and has now resulted in a massive debt burden that the country is facing.
“After ruining India’s economic growth story, creating huge unemployment, raging inflation, Mr Modi has done the unthinkable, which is an addition of over Rs 100 lakh crore to India’s debt, which is at an alarming level,” she said at a press conference.
The Congress leader further said India’s debt in 2014 was at Rs 55 lakh crore, which has now gone past Rs 155 lakh crore.
She claimed that India’s debt under 14 prime ministers in 67 years was Rs 55 lakh crore while Modi alone has increased it by over Rs 100 lakh crore.
“Economic management is not the same thing as headline management. The Indian economy cannot be managed by managing headlines. It cannot be done through teleprompters and definitely not through WhatsApp forwards. The Indian economy will have to be managed by sound economic managers who don’t want to hog the limelight. Who wants to do the work and fix the Indian economy and ensure that prosperity reaches every part of India?
“We demand a white paper on the Indian economy because the fault lines are only getting deeper,” she said.
Shrinate also claimed that the bottom 50 per cent of Indians who own three per cent of the country’s wealth paid 64 per cent of the GST collected. The richest 10 per cent, on the other hand, own 80 per cent of the country’s wealth but pay only three per cent of the GST collected.
India has the costliest LPG cylinder, the third costliest petrol and the eighth costliest diesel in the world, Shrinate claimed.
The Congress leader said a debt of Rs 155 lakh crore means every Indian is reeling under a burden of Rs 1.20 lakh.
“The Modi government in its tenure has bought debt of Rs 4 lakh rupees every second,” she claimed.
The Congress spokesperson also added that the government has to pay an annual interest of Rs 11 lakh crore on this debt.
India’s debt-to-GDP ratio has risen to 84 per cent, Shrinate claimed, and said it is alarming when compared to other developing and emerging market economies where the average debt-to-GDP ratio is at 64.5 per cent.
“India is bearing an annual cost of Rs 11 lakh crore to service this mounting debt. Questions are now being raised on India’s debt servicing capacity. According to the CAG report, government debt was 52.5 per cent of GDP in 2019-20 and the debt sustainability had turned negative that year. With debt at 84 per cent of the GDP, debt sustainability is suspect,” she asserted.
“But, the big question is who are the beneficiaries of this rising debt because quite clearly it is not the poor, not the middle class and not the MSMEs. Twenty-three crore people have been pushed below the poverty line, 83 per cent Indians have seen their incomes dip, over 11,000 MSMEs have shut down in a single year but the number of billionaires in India have gone up from 102 in 2020 to 166 over two years.
“But are all these rich beneficiaries of high debt playing their part in India’s growth or paying higher taxes?” Shrinate asked and said the government should turn its focus to the other important issue of tax collection.
Price rise and unemployment, besides income disparity, have emerged as major issues, she said.
“The bottom 50 per cent of India’s population that owns just three per cent of the country’s total wealth is paying 64 per cent of the GST collected. In contrast, the top 10 per cent richest Indians, who own 80 per cent of the country’s wealth, pay merely 3-4 per cent of the GST collected,” the Congress leader claimed.
“The government is clearly in denial because it is certain that an indirect tax like the GST or excise duty on fuel has hurt the poor the most. India’s consumption has been consistently weak. The recently released GDP figures that the government touted as a great achievement has a very big red flag — India’s consumption-to-GDP ratio has fallen from 61.1 per cent in FY 2022 to 60.6 per cent in FY 2023,” she said.
Asked if India is on a path similar to Sri Lanka and Pakistan, she said, “No, I am not going to sit here and say that we can go the Sri Lanka and the Pakistan way.”
Elaborating further on her stance, the Congress leader said, “I think the fundamentals of our economy are strong, they need to be strengthened. I don’t think I am going to sit here and do rumour-mongering. But yes, while the fundamentals are strong, perhaps, we have a consumption story. We have an India that will spend if you put money in their hands but the reality also is that in the last nine years there has been no focus on economic management.”
She added, “The mainstay of the Indian economy is consumption. Any government should lose sleep if consumption begins to default and that is what is happening. If consumption begins to default, we must worry, but I will not do rumour-mongering.”
