Sean “Diddy” Combs’ request to be detained under house arrest at his luxury Star Island property in Florida was rejected by US District Judge Arun Subramanian. The hip-hop mogul, awaiting trial on charges of sex trafficking and abuse, had proposed the $35 million mansion as an alternative to his current detention at Brooklyn’s Metropolitan Detention Center.The judge dismissed the proposal, asserting it would not mitigate risks posed by Combs’ alleged obstruction and dangerousness.
Inside ‘Star Island’
While the trial progresses, Star Island’s allure has drawn attention. Known for its exclusivity, the island boasts luxury homes, waterfront views, and proximity to Miami’s amenities. Here’s what makes it unique, as reported by Fox Business:
- In 2003, Diddy purchased a nine-bedroom mansion for $14.5 million.
- In 2021, Diddy bought the neighbouring estate for $35 million, adding an 8,000-square-foot house with six bedrooms and 10 bathrooms to his collection.
- Accessibility: Only reachable via a single bridge or private dock.
- Prestige: Home to A-listers, including Jennifer Lopez and Gloria Estefan.
- Privacy: Gated community with private security.
- Amenities: Close to downtown Miami, top restaurants, and airports.
‘The defendant cannot be trusted’
Combs’ lawyers argued during Friday’s hearing that the musician should be allowed to prepare for his May 2024 trial under strict surveillance at either his Florida mansion or a Manhattan apartment.
The defence insisted the arrangement would be “more restrictive” than his current incarceration. “It would be impossible for him not to follow the rules,” attorney Teny Geragos said, highlighting Combs’ willingness to comply with such conditions.
However, prosecutors maintained that no conditions could ensure public safety or prevent interference with the case. They accused Combs of orchestrating social media campaigns to influence jurors and using intermediaries to contact potential witnesses while in custody.
“This is about accountability,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Christy Slavik stated. “The defendant cannot be trusted.”
Judge’s decision
Despite the defence’s arguments, Judge Subramanian rejected the request outright. “That is not going to work,” he said, talkin about the need for stringent detention to prevent any potential tampering or threats to witnesses.
Combs remains incarcerated at the Brooklyn jail as his trial nears. The court is expected to rule on additional bail requests in the coming weeks, but the judge’s firm stance suggests a high bar for any future appeals.
